First-time homeowners Nikki and Noah Anderson are delighted to find an affordable starter home within commuting distance of NYC. The neighborhood is absolutely adorable, and everyone is so friendly and welcoming. Between potlucks and white picket fences, it’s an idyllic suburban dream. Or is it? Because something feels . . . off. The neighbors smile a little too much. There are strange sounds in the night. And then there’s the pair of wedding rings they find buried in their backyard . . . The suburbs have their share of dark secrets, too. And by the time Nikki and Noah realize it, it might already be too late.